Home
 
 
   
Is there a great danger of "fad diagnosis" in the sleep disorder field?

Question:
Reason I ask: I fully well believe that I might have sleep troubles (apnea) and plan to go to a doctor, yea, even a sleep specialist. But I'm looking for techniques to recognize and deal with two kinds of doctors I might encounter:

* those that would too quickly jump to the conclusion that a sleep disorder is responsible for my problems

* those that would rebel against such a diagnosis because they see it as a "fad" diagnosis.

Please read carefully. I NEVER said in this message it's "all in the head" or "sleep apnea doesn't exist". Rather, I'm asking what percautions should I take, such that I don't get falsely diagnosed with apnea when it might be thyroid problem, the beginnings of diabetes, depression, or something else; and, on the other hand, what does it take to get an overly skeptical doctor to explore sleep disorders as an option, and to refer me to the appropriate specialists.

In other words, in your experience, how has the perception of sleep disorders as something only recently publicized affect the doctor's impartiality, and how does one deal with this?


Answer:
I have come across doctors that said sleep apnea did not exist but finally found one that took it serious enought to sent me to a specialist And now have been on CPAP for nearly 4 years and have got heaps of benifits from it was unable to keep a job before they don't like it when you fall to sleep at the desk but since about 1 month after CPAP have had a job.

Yes, I understand that. Read carefully. I didn't say "Well, I think I kinda might have a problem but I don't plan to do anything, convince me that I need to look out for my health." I said "I plan to do something. What techniques do you use to recognize doctors that know what's going on?"

I'm autistic (Asperger's) and I have a hard time figuring out when a doctor knows what's going on, because there are all sorts of nonverbal cues given in the diagnosis problem. I've festered with infections gone wild, been dismissed as perfectly healthy in the midst of serious depressive problems, and had other similar things happen to me, all because I don't _emote_ and _nonverbally cue_ doctors the way they expect from the typical patient.

SO, I'm honestly asking for a list of techniquest to tell whether the doctors are too _quick_ or too _slow_ to settle on sleep disorders, and things one can say to get them to shift gears. Or rapid ways to recognize evasion in the specific case of sleep disorders. Are there specific words that help when describing my problems, and specific ways of explaining my difficulties that will mislead a doctor into thinking "This man just saw too many paid television spots". Because that _is_ how I first found out that it might describe what's wrong with me, and there are doctors out there that pooh-pooh anything new and unfamiliar that might explain a specific problem. I want to explore it fully along with the possibility of thyroid problems which are also hereditary in my family.

I've already gotten a few flame Emails saying "You're stalling, go get diagnosed." But anyone who has lurked on this group for more than a few days knows that it isn't just that easy. I _WANT_ CPAP if it will help me, but I have another specific medical/psychological problem in dealing with doctors (lack of facility in nonverbal communication) and wanted some input.

My only problem was not stating it this clearly the first time around. I hope this clears up the misconceptions about what I was asking.

Research is always a good start. Knowing you display symptoms that can indicate a sleep disorder should convince a doctor that a referral to a sleep clinic for assessment is worth exploring. If it doesn't, its a good indicator to switch doctors.

The assessment at the clinic is unlikely to result in a "fad diagnosis" - when you're wired to the sensors its difficult to manipulate results.

I doubt you will have problems, though. You are able to enunciate your concerns clearly and have identified certain probabilities with similar symptoms that should be ruled in or out - apnea, thyroid, diabetes, depression.

The first three have simple tests for screening. Even if one is confirmed the other two are still a possibility. Screening for all three should occur - as well as looking for other possibilities. Lots of other internal organs can cause similar problems and there are some nasty "invaders" out there.

It is possible a doctor might want to eliminate certain possibilities first before deciding on a sleep test. My concern would how much time would be lost.

It is not unusual for depression to be associated with physical ailments. Depending on how long it would take to get test results and start treatment - assuming one or more physical problems show up -and how severe the depression is it might be advisable to commence treatment for depression right away.

If you are less articulate in a doctor's office than in email, write everything out before you go. Include displayed symptoms, associated ailments, questions and a statement about the level of involvement you expect in planning your assessments and subsequent treatment.




What is Your answer?


 
Privacy Policy